Psych Safety← Measuring Psychological Safety
  1. Psych Safety
  2. Measure
  3. Benchmarking

Reading results

Why we don’t benchmark psychological safety

Your results are never compared with other teams: no percentiles, no “teams like yours”, no league tables. Here is why, and what to compare with instead.

The first thing many people ask of a psychological safety survey is how their team compares. It is a reasonable question, and we have built the tool so that it cannot be answered. This page says why.

What a benchmark promises

A benchmark promises context: 3.8 means little on its own, but 3.8 against an industry average of 3.4 feels like a result. It promises a target. And it promises a way to show progress to someone who was not in the room.

What it does instead

What to compare with instead

Your own past. The second survey of the same team shows what changed, theme by theme, after the team acted on the first. That is a comparison the team controls, cannot be gamed by anyone else’s numbers, and reads as a prompt for a conversation about what happened in between.

Within the team, compare statements with each other: where people agree, where they split, which theme sits lowest. And compare reasons: a team whose quiet people mostly report futility needs something different from one whose quiet people mostly report cost.

Across an organisation

An organisation licence pools what teams report: which reasons for holding back recur, what helps people speak up, how the picture moves as teams measure again. It never shows a league table, never ranks teams, and never opens a team’s own report, including to the people paying for it. If you want to know which teams are struggling, ask them. If a number exposes a team to its own management, expect that team to answer the next survey more carefully.

If someone insists on a number

Boards and funders sometimes need one. Give them what the team is doing and when it will measure again, rather than a score against strangers. Never tie a psychological safety result to a manager’s pay or rating; once a score decides someone’s standing, people learn to manage the score, and the next survey tells you less. Our principles of ethical measurement set this out at length.

Questions

Is there an industry benchmark for psychological safety?

Not one worth using. Scores depend on the exact wording, the moment and who answered, so a comparison across organisations compares different things. Measure never shows percentiles, league tables or “teams like yours”. A team’s only meaningful comparison is with its own past.

What is a good psychological safety score?

There isn’t one. Look at the spread of answers, the lowest answer and the reasons people give for holding back. A high average can hide two people who feel silenced, and that is not a good result whatever the benchmark says.

Can I compare teams within my own organisation?

You can pool patterns: which reasons for holding back recur and what helps people speak. Measure’s organisation view does that without ranking teams or opening any team’s own report. Ranking teams tends to teach everyone to manage the number instead of the conditions.

Why does Measure not show percentiles?

Because comparison turns a conversation into a target. Once a team knows it is being compared, the quickest way up is to answer more generously, and after a survey or two the number tells you little.

Also on reading results
Build a team surveySee a sample reportSee the survey questions

↑ Back to the top